Four masked men allegedly rob Ogden man after woman leads them to residence, charges say

OGDEN, Utah (ABC4) — Four people have been charged after an alleged robbery and assault in Ogden. Police say that a woman asked to visit the victim, then had four masked men break in and rob him at gunpoint.

Crissa Courtney Shaw, 25, Ayden Anthony Valencia, 19, and Carter Cory Jones, 27, have all been charged with felony aggravated robbery and felony aggravated assault. Anthony Joseph Lilly, 19, has been charged with conspiring to commit aggravated robbery, obstruction of justice, and conspiring to commit aggravated assault.

According to documents, on May 13, 2025, Ogden Police officers were called to the 800 block of Wood Street in Ogden. A victim reported that he had been attacked and robbed by a group of people.

Shaw, who was previously in a relationship with the victim, had called the victim and asked him if she could come to his residence, documents say. Almost immediately after she went into the home, four masked men entered the residence and came downstairs.

According to police, the victim saw that one of the men was carrying a machete, another had a short-barreled rifle, and a third had a handgun. The man with the rifle told the victim that if he “tried anything,” he would “shoot him in the leg.”

The four masked men stole multiple items from the victim’s residence, including jewelry, electronics, tools, and keys. Shaw left with one of the male suspects while the victim was held at gunpoint and his home was ransacked.

After the robbery, the group left together in a dark blue passenger car that was missing a rear driver’s side hubcap, as identified on security footage. Surveillance video captured the vehicle in several places around Ogden City on the night of the robbery.

Shaw was located and arrested by police first. She was charged on May 19 and is being held in the Weber County Jail. A search warrant was served for her phone, and photos of a man wearing a hat seen on surveillance footage were found on the device.

Ogden officers were able to track down Jones due to the distinct hat he was wearing, and they identified his blue Honda Civic as the vehicle used to flee the scene. He was arrested on May 20 and charged the next day.

During the investigation, Valencia was identified as a possible suspect. Police served a search warrant on his phone and located a conversation from the day before the robbery between him and Lilly. Valencia told Lilly that he had a “lick” planned and discussed acquiring firearms and ammunition.

A search of Lilly’s house revealed that he had a firearm concealed in cat litter. He was arrested and later charged on June 5 for his role in the robbery. While at the jail, he allegedly made a call and instructed someone on wiping information from his phone remotely.

Valencia admitted to police that he had been involved in the robbery and assault. He was charged on June 5, and he said that he had brandished a firearm at the victim while the robbery was occurring.

Shaw, Jones, Lilly, and Valencia have all been booked into the Weber County Jail and are being held without bail. Neither charges nor an arrest have been filed against the fourth masked individual involved in the robbery.