Papa Johns just unveiled what might be its most daring innovation yet: the Croissant
Except one.
They didn’t buy CroissantPizza*com.
Yes, you read that right. In 2025, in an era where owning your digital real estate is everything, Papa Johns launched a globally marketed product without acquiring the exact-match domain name for one of its new crown jewels.
As someone who has built and sold domain names, invested in branding strategies for major franchises, and studied QSR marketing campaigns in depth—this is not just a minor oversight. It’s a missed branding opportunity, a strategic lapse, and frankly, a marketing fumble that cost them just $14.
Let’s break down how an otherwise brilliant product launch ended up with a hole in its crust.
To be clear, Papa Johns did a lot right with this launch.
In other words, this was a well-researched, strategically executed, and culturally relevant launch.
Which makes the domain name oversight even more baffling.
In the branding world, digital is everything. A memorable domain name is not just a URL—it’s a marketing asset, a trust signal, and in many cases, a search magnet.
Here’s why CroissantPizza*com should have been part of Papa Johns’ pre-launch checklist:
The term croissant pizza is now going to spike in global search interest thanks to the campaign. By not owning the exact-match domain, Papa Johns has no control over:
It’s the equivalent of building a flagship store and forgetting to hang the sign outside.
Consumers expect legitimacy. When they search for “croissant pizza,” they’re subconsciously scanning for URLs that match their intent. If someone else owns CroissantPizza*com and populates it with affiliate ads, clickbait, or worse—Papa Johns risks brand confusion and consumer drop-off. Of course putting on my Ruskin Moscou Faltischek, P.C. lawyer hat there can possibly be trademark issues here too…
Imagine running an influencer campaign or TikTok ad where “link in bio” directs to CroissantPizza*com—a domain that Papa Johns doesn’t own. Every campaign asset (QR codes, PPC, social CTAs) is weakened without a clear, ownable destination.
Even now, Papa Johns is vulnerable to a cyber-squatter buying the domain and redirecting traffic. Worse? A competitor like Domino’s , Pizza Hut , Marco’s Pizza (Marco’s Franchising, LLC), etc. could use the domain to hijack the narrative or confuse consumers. In the franchise world, this is a serious threat to brand equity.
That’s all it would have cost: $14 to register CroissantPizza*com. For a multi-billion dollar brand like Papa Johns, this is loose change—less than the cost of one Croissant Pizza combo meal.
As of today, CroissantPizza*com is still unregistered (at least at the time of writing). This isn’t just a “teachable moment”—it’s a textbook case study.
Papa Johns is a major player, but this blunder reveals a blind spot even in top-tier marketing departments. Here’s what could have avoided this issue:
Before launching any new product name, brands should lock down all relevant:
Even if the product is temporary, the keyword lives forever. Papa Johns should have:
With CroissantPizza*com, Papa Johns could have:
Whether you’re a global QSR brand or a regional upstart, digital real estate matters. Domain names are your first impression. They guide your narrative, enhance your SEO, and protect your brand from dilution or hijacking.
Papa Johns had a world-class product, a daring creative collaboration, and a global rollout strategy—but they forgot to secure the front door to the house they just built.
The Croissant Pizza will likely perform well. Its visual appeal alone makes it Instagrammable and TikTok-worthy. The mashup trend has legs, and if the taste matches the marketing hype, consumers will eat it up—literally.
But if Papa Johns wants to fully capitalize, they need to think digitally-first going forward.
They could still:
In short, they can still save this slice.
Because in today’s world, it’s not just about better ingredients and better pizza—it’s also about better digital branding.
If you happen to register any of the domain names (for less than $14) please keep me updated as I always like to see what happens with the domain names I discover.
If you are interested in learning about available expired domains I discover BEFORE the public, then please consider signing-up for my Domain Alerts here
To your domaining success,
@AndrewHazen & @DomainSuccess
Join our Domain Success Newsletter
Join my Prime Marketing Strategies Newsletter
Pixar's Hoppers, about a young animal rights activist (Piper Curda) who transfers her mind into…
After more than five years since the last book in the series was published, Sarah…
A giant power line was knocked down Friday evening after a truck crashed into it.
Students at Caledonia Elementary School were sent home Friday morning after heavy rainfall caused flooding…
On its Early Access launch day, before I'd unlocked anything, I was struck by how…
BriTanya Brown, an independent candidate for Texas House District 71, discusses her motivations for running,…
This website uses cookies.