Hundreds of Catholics gather in San Francisco to decry COVID-19 limits on worship

CLICK HERE if you’re having a problem viewing the photos on a mobile device.

As churches across the country are welcoming parishioners back inside their doors for the first time in months, Bay Area faith leaders and worshipers are growing increasingly rancorous with strict constraints public health officials continue to place upon their gatherings.

Several hundred Catholics gathered Sunday morning in front of San Francisco City Hall for a “Free the Mass” demonstration and march led by San Francisco Archbishop Salvatore Joseph Cordileone, who asked congregants earlier this week to join him in a public call on public officials to reopen churches for worship at a “level consistent with other activities” in the city.

The Catholic marchers — many wearing matching ‘We are Essential’ T-shirts and holding signs that read messages like ‘We are not treated the same, nor heard the same’ and ‘We need the holy Eucharist’ — walked together nearly a mile to the Cathedral of Saint Mary for a large-scale outdoor worship service, likely one of the largest religious gatherings in the region in months.

Maria Herrara, a parishioner at St. Peter’s Church in the Mission District for the past 14 years, banged a tambourine to the beat of the church hymns that the group sang in Spanish. They walked in four single-file lines through the streets, guided by ropes that extended several blocks long to keep them distanced by several feet.

“There’s a lot of bad news all around us — people losing jobs, losing family, getting sick and losing the schools,” Herrera said. “This is the time when you really need God and the Holy Eucharist in your life.”

The reopening rules for worship services in the Bay Area remain some of the strictest mandates for religious services in the country. In most counties, including Santa Clara and Alameda, indoor religious gathering are prohibited but worshippers are allowed to gather outdoors without a capacity limit.

In San Francisco, up to 50 people to gather for outdoor worship and one person may go inside a religious institution at a time for individual prayer indoors. The city plans to allow for indoor services up to a maximum of 25 people by Oct. 1. But in a church like San Francisco’s St. Mary’s Cathedral, that equates to less than 1% of the facility’s capacity, according to Cordileone.

Meanwhile, people are allowed to eat outdoors on restaurant patios with no set capacity limits and indoor shopping malls are allowed to operate at 25% capacity.

Cordileone wrote an op-ed in the Washington Post earlier this week, saying that government officials were denying Americans right to worship and that he could no longer sit silent in the face of the unjust treatment.

During his homily in front of the Cathedral, the archbishop called the regulations San Francisco has placed on the churches an “insult” and a “mockery.”

“The city continues to place unrealistic and suffocating restrictions on our natural and constitutional right to worship,” Cordileone said. “This discrimination affects all of us.”

“…They (officials in City Hall) are mocking you, and even worse, they are mocking God,” he added later.

As state and local public health officials have instituted mandates to stem the spread of COVID-19, the right to worship has become a fierce debate. Nationwide, several churches have even sued to halt the restrictions.

Santa Clara’s North Valley Baptist Church racked up more than $100,000 in fines for holding indoor services last month in defiance of a county ban. The church, which has some 3,000 worshippers, moved its service outside after county officials threatened to seek a court order.

Still, many public officials have stood by the restrictions. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi pushed back Friday against Cordileone’s criticism of COVID-related restrictions, saying he should “follow science” rather than advocate for fuller in-person gatherings for Mass and worship.

Grace Vest, 39, of Pleasant Hill, called the restrictions that San Fransisco has placed on religious institutions “harsh” and “overwrought.” Vest, a former San Francisco resident, drove about 30 minutes with her husband and four children into the city Sunday morning to attend the march and support the archbishop.

“People can grumble and complain but the archbishop decided to actually take a stand and demand that we have families that are able to worship here,” she said.

While most Bay Area churches turned to platforms like Zoom and Facebook Live to hold services for their congregants at home, many religious leaders and followers believe that if proper health recommendations are followed — such as six feet of space between chairs and mask requirements — are followed, they should be allowed to reopen for in-person worship.

Vest, for instance, compared watching church services on Zoom over the past six months to her children’s experience with distance learning.

“It’s just not real,” she said. “When we’re able to come together — even if we’re distanced — we’re all praying together and it’s just something you cannot replace.”

Go to Source
Author: Maggie Angst

EastBayTimes